HP Store Online

Should I replace my Mac logic board or buy a new computer?

The logic board to my white macbook of 2 years is damaged ( probably because I dropped it twice on the cement freshman year). It has microsoft office (which I need for school) and it's been upgraded to 4 GB of RAM. My college computer services will replace the logic board for $470 (includes price of the logic board and labor). Should I just repair my Macbook or buy a new computer. The thing is if I buy a new computer, I would probably buy a dell or HP that is around $500-650 without tax. I know these computers are less durable than a Mac. On top of that I'd be getting the minimum accessories on my computer. I also would have to invest in buying virus software and buy Microsoft Office. I think it's better to just repair my Macbook. At least I know it's a durable computer and has everything I need on it already. However, my cousin who works at best buy says it's not worth it and just to buy a new computer. What should I do?

Public Comments

1. I'm pretty sure Apple will swap out the logic board for $300.00. Check with them first. As far as longevity, you are better off repairing the MacBook. Macs generally have twice the useful lifespan of PCs (which are generally outdated after 3 years; the DoD has a mandatory 3-year upgrade rule). Your cousin at Best Buy likely has this 3-year PC "rule" in mind - which, of course, does not apply to Macs. My Mom still gets by with her 1999 iMac.
2. It's unlikely you can replace that motherboard for less than the computer is worth. It's very likely you'll spend $400 trying, just to find out there's other damage. Macs aren't that durable. I take care of them for a company and they rarely last as long as the Dells. You can get the regular Macbook in the aluminum case now if you buy the new one. It's a lot tougher than the plastic ones.